De Scott Evans

The Irish Question

1880s
Oil on canvas
30.5 × 25.4 cm (12 × 10 in)

SEE IT IN PERSON

Not currently on view

In the collection of Art Institute of Chicago, Chicago · as of July 2026

View at artic.eduPlan a visit ↗

Discussion

FROM THE ART INSTITUTE OF CHICAGO’S CATALOG

A seemingly uncomplicated representation of two potatoes suspended by a string against a wood panel, The Irish Question is an unusual and striking trompe l’oeil painting that raises numerous questions. The title may refer to the troubled status of the Irish in the late 19th century; the hanging potatoes inflect this allusion with either ominous overtones or a dark sense of humor. Illusionistic paintings such as The Irish Question offer an enjoyable form of visual deception, and the pseudonymous signature “S.S. David” suggests that De Scott Evans relished the opportunity to puzzle his viewers on many levels.

Source ↗

Be the first to share your thoughts.

Sign in to join the discussion.

Community guidelines

More like this

Basket of PotatoesVincent van Gogh — Basket of PotatoesStill Life with PotatoesVincent van Gogh — Still Life with PotatoesBaskets of PotatoesVincent van Gogh — Baskets of PotatoesStill Life with Quinces, Medlars and a GlassMartinus Nellius — Still Life with Quinces, Medlars and a GlStill Life with a Basket of Apples and Two PumpkinsVincent van Gogh — Still Life with a Basket of Apples and TwDrie perziken op een stenen plintAdriaen Coorte — Drie perziken op een stenen plintKitchen Utensils with Leeks, Fish, and EggsJean-Siméon Chardin (French, 1699–1779) — Kitchen Utensils wStill Life with Chickens and EggsGiovanni Battista Recco — Still Life with Chickens and EggsStill Life with Fish, Bread, and KettleLuis Meléndez (Spanish, 1716–1780) — Still Life with Fish, BStill Life with Game FowlJuan Sánchez Cotán — Still Life with Game FowlStill Life with FishPieter de Putter — Still Life with FishStill Life with Cabbage and ClogsVincent van Gogh — Still Life with Cabbage and Clogs